Throughout most of my life, I’ve been captivated by enigmas, whether it’s delving into a Dateline NBC true crime murder mystery (like the intricate Lori Vallow/Chad Daybell “Cult Mom” case), engaging in a game of Clue, immersing myself in a suspenseful book with a cryptic plot (such as “The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo”), or participating in one of those theatrical murder mystery dinners (“Could it be me, the culprit?”).

So, naturally, I was compelled to delve into an FBI list from 2005 that highlights the most significant mysteries and crimes within the realm of art.

“The most beautiful thing we can experience is the mysterious. It is the source of all true art and science.”

Albert Einstein

Until I started college and met my wife, art didn’t particularly captivate me. I had some awareness of renowned works like the Mona Lisa, Rosetta Stone, The Thinker, and The Last Supper, but my interest didn’t extend much beyond that.

My wife’s passion for museums led us to explore several during our travels, and that opened my eyes to the allure and magnificence of artwork. A few days ago, my 2024 “page-a-day” calendar, featuring unexplained mysteries, highlighted the theft of Caravaggio’s Nativity with St. Francis and St. Lawrence, sparking my curiosity about other art thefts. Intrigued, I delved into research and decided to share my findings in today’s blog post. I’ll be discussing the FBI’s list of the 10 biggest art crimes, and I hope you’ll join me in exploring this fascinating topic!

NATIVITY WITH ST. FRANCIS AND ST. LAWRENCE (CARAVAGGIO)

A painting by Italian Caravaggio, this masterpiece created in 1609 has been missing since 1969, when it was stolen from the Oratory of Saint Lawrence in Palermo, Italy.

Value: $20 Million

Suspected to have been stolen by several thieves and then passed around within the Sicilian Mafia for years after the theft, in 2015 a replica was commissioned by Sky Broadcasting, and using the high technology of Factum Arte, a high-resolution copy of the stolen artwork was created and hung in the altar on December 12, 2015.

THE DAVID-MORINI STRADIVARIUS

In October 1995, a Stradivarius violin was stolen from the New York City apartment of Erica Morini, a renowned concert violinist. The instrument, known as the Davidoff-Morini Stradivarius, was made in 1727 by the legendary violin maker Antonio Stradivari.

Value: $3 Million

Interestingly, this was no random break-in; rather, it appears to have been a planned theft orchestrated by a small circle of individuals who had access to Morini’s apartment and the key to the wardrobe where she kept the violin. Despite extensive investigations, the crime remains unsolved to this day.

GERTRUDE VANDERBILT WHITNEY MURALS

In July 2002, two oil paintings by Maxfield Parrish were stolen during a burglary of a gallery in West Hollywood, California. These paintings are two panels from a series commissioned for Gertrude Vanderbilt Whitney’s 5th Avenue mansion in New York.

Value: $4 Million

The stolen artworks were cut from their frames during the theft. Unfortunately, despite extensive efforts, the missing murals have not been recovered, leaving a fascinating art mystery unsolved.

MADELEINE LEANING ON HER ELBOW WITH FLOWERS IN HER HAIR (RENOIR)

The priceless oil painting crafted by the celebrated French Impressionist maestro Pierre-Auguste Renoir was brazenly snatched during an armed robbery at a residence in Houston on September 8, 2011.

Value: $22 Million

The masked robber brandished a powerful, semi-automatic handgun as they made off with the painting, which vanished from its frame without a trace. This baffling disappearance has left art enthusiasts and investigators perplexed. A private insurer has stepped forward, offering a substantial reward of up to $50,000 for any information that could aid in the recovery of this priceless artwork.

A CAVALIER (VAN MIERIS)

On June 10, 2007, this precious artwork was stolen from the Art Gallery of New South Wales in Sydney, Australia. The audacious theft occurred while the gallery was open for public viewing, adding an element of daring to the crime.

Value: $1 Million

“A Cavalier” is a captivating self-portrait painted by Frans van Mieris the Elder in 1657. It showcases the artist’s skillful rendering and attention to detail. The painting had been donated to the gallery in 1993 by media figure and philanthropist James Fairfax.

MUSEU CHACARA DO CÉU, RIO DE JANEIRO

In 2006, during Rio de Janeiro’s exuberant Carnival celebrations, a group of audacious thieves executed a daring heist at the Chácara do Céu Museum. Their target? Priceless artworks by some of the most renowned modern artists. The stolen masterpieces included Claude Monet’s “Marine,” Salvador Dalí’s “The Two Balcony,” Henri Matisse’s “The Luxemburg Gardens,” and Pablo Picasso’s “The Dance.”

Value: Priceless

Despite investigations spanning 15 years, the stolen art has never resurfaced, leaving art enthusiasts and investigators alike pondering their whereabouts.

ISABELLA STEWART GARDNER MUSEUM THEFT

In 1990, 13 valuable artworks were stolen from the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum in Boston. The thieves posed as police officers, bound the guards, and looted the museum. Notable pieces include a Vermeer painting and Rembrandt’s seascape. 

Value: Hundreds of Millions $$$

Empty frames still hang in the museum as placeholders for the missing works, and the museum offers a $10 million reward for information leading to their recovery. The mystery continues to captivate art enthusiasts and investigators.

THE IRAQ NATIONAL MUSEUM LOOTING

In April 2003, during the chaos following the U.S. invasion of Iraq, the National Museum of Iraq in Baghdad suffered a devastating looting incident. Thieves, taking advantage of the turmoil, ransacked the museum over a 36-hour period. 

Value: Priceless

While the museum staff had managed to safely store 8,366 artifacts, approximately 15,000 objects were stolen. These priceless pieces included ancient Sumerian artifacts, sculptures, pottery, and cylinder seals. Despite efforts to recover the stolen art, more than 8,000 artifacts remain unaccounted for.

EDVARD MUNCH’S THE SCREAM

In a daring heist that unfolded during the opening day of the Winter Olympics in Lillehammer, Norway, two audacious thieves targeted the National Gallery in Oslo. Their target: the 1893 version of “The Scream,” an iconic painting depicting a ghostly figure against a fiery orange sky on a bridge. In a mere 50 seconds, the thieves cut the wire holding the painting to the wall and vanished.

Value: $120 Million

The Norwegian government received a $1 million ransom demand but refused to pay. Eventually, four men were convicted in connection with the theft, including Paal Enger, who had previously stolen another Munch masterpiece, “The Vampire,” in Oslo. The audacity of this theft remains etched in art history, adding intrigue to the already enigmatic allure of “The Scream.”

SWEDISH NATIONAL MUSEUM THEFT

In December 2000, daring thieves targeted the National Museum in Stockholm, Sweden. Armed with weapons, they stole three valuable paintings: a self-portrait by Rembrandt and two Renoir works (“Conversation” and “Young Parisian”). 

Value: $30-45 Million

The robbers escaped in a motorboat, throwing nails on the road to hinder police pursuit. Although the masterminds were arrested, the paintings remained missing for years. In 2005, the FBI uncovered a lead in Los Angeles, eventually recovering both paintings.


NOW IT’S YOUR TURN

Share your absolute favorite works of art in the comments below and let’s ignite a passionate discussion!

2 responses to “FBI’S TOP 10 ART CRIMES: UNSOLVED MYSTERIES AND STOLEN TREASURES”

  1. […] FBI’S TOP 10 ART CRIMES: UNSOLVED MYSTERIES AND STOLEN TREASURES […]

    Like

  2. […] FBI’S TOP 10 ART CRIMES: UNSOLVED MYSTERIES AND STOLEN TREASURES […]

    Like

Trending

Discover more from MOTEVENTURE

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading